In recent years, Orange DUI lawyers have seen DUI cases take a significant shift, adjusting from primarily alcohol-related DUIs to drug DUIs; those involving drugs, including prescription and illegal substances. As a result, the roles involved in DUI investigations have also expanded, incorporating specialists known as Drug Recognition Experts (DREs). These experts play a critical part in evaluating drivers suspected of drug impairment, significantly influencing the progression and outcome of DUI cases. This article delves into the responsibilities of DREs, their impact on DUI investigations, and essential considerations for defendants navigating the complexities of such cases.
Who is a Drug Recognition Expert (DRE)?
A Drug Recognition Expert is a law enforcement officer specifically trained to identify drug-impaired drivers. Unlike standard police officers, DREs undergo extensive training in pharmacology, physiology, and the psychophysical effects of various substances on the human body. Their training helps them to ascertain actual impairment resulting from drug use, which often differs significantly from alcohol impairment.
The DRE program, initially developed by the Los Angeles Police Department, is now a standardized method employed by law enforcement agencies across the United States. This program equips officers with the skills needed to administer a 12-step evaluation process in DUI investigations.
The 12-Step DRE Evaluation Process
The DRE process is a comprehensive protocol that aids in identifying the presence and category of drugs in a suspect’s system. Here is an outline of the 12-step procedure:
1. Breath Alcohol Test: The initial step involves administering a breath alcohol test to rule out alcohol as the primary cause of impairment.
2. Interview of the Arresting Officer: The DRE consults with the arresting officer to gather accounts of the suspect’s driving patterns and behavior during the initial arrest.
3. Preliminary Examination and Interview: Conducting an initial questioning session to observe the suspect’s behavior and ensure they do not have medical conditions mimicking drug impairment.
4. Eye Examinations: Evaluating the suspect’s eyes for signs of impairment, such as nystagmus (involuntary jerking) or unusual pupil dilation.
5. Divided Attention Tests: Administering field sobriety tests that evaluate balance, coordination, and the ability to multitask.
6. Vital Signs Examination: Measurement of blood pressure, temperature, and pulse provides clues about drug use.
7. Dark Room Examinations: Checking the eyes under different lighting conditions to observe pupil reactions.
8. Muscle Tone Check: Certain drugs can cause muscle rigidity or flaccidity, which this step helps identify.
9. Injection Site Examination: Looking for direct evidence of drug use through inspection of possible injection sites.
10. Suspect’s Statements: Engaging the suspect in conversation to potentially obtain admissions regarding drug use.
11. Expert Opinion: Formulating an opinion based on the evidence gathered during the evaluation.
12. Toxicological Examination: Ascertaining the presence of drugs through laboratory analysis for confirmation.
The Impact of DREs on DUI Investigations
The expertise of a DRE can greatly influence the course of a DUI investigation and potential prosecution in the Central Justice Center. Given their specialized training, their testimony holds substantial weight in court, particularly when determining the presence and effects of drugs.
1. Accuracy Improvement: DREs contribute to more accurate assessments of drug impairment, thus enhancing the reliability of DUI charges. Their involvement helps bridge the gap in cases where typical field sobriety tests might not clearly indicate impairment, especially since these tests were predominantly developed for alcohol rather than drugs.
2. Influence on Legal Outcomes: A DRE’s findings can be pivotal in the Orange County District Attorney’s case. Their reports often serve as key evidence, determining whether a DUI charge moves forward or is dropped due to insufficient evidence of impairment.
Challenges in DRE Testimony
Despite their credentials, DREs are not immune to challenges, especially from skillful Orange DUI attorneys who may question the reliability of their evaluations. There are several potential defenses against DRE testimony:
1. Questioning the Methodology: Orange DUI lawyers can scrutinize the 12-step DRE evaluation process. They might argue that certain physical conditions or mental health issues could mimic drug impairment symptoms, thus challenging the validity of the DRE’s observations.
2. Training and Certification: The defense could investigate the particular DRE’s experience and the frequency of their evaluations to ensure their proficiency and current certification status.
3. Cross-Examination of Subjective Findings: Many steps in the DRE process involve a certain level of subjectivity, providing an opportunity for cross-examination by your Orange DUI attorney to highlight potential observer bias or misinterpretation.
Defendant Considerations
For defendants in DUI cases involving DRE evidence, it is vital to comprehend the implications of such testimony and work closely with an experienced Orange County DUI attorney who specializes in drug-related cases. Several steps can be taken to prepare:
1. Evidence Evaluation: An Orange County DUI lawyer will meticulously evaluate all evidence, including DRE findings, to identify weaknesses or inconsistencies that could work in the defendant’s favor.
2. Expert Witnesses: Your Orange DUI attorney might consider hiring their own medical or drug recognition expert to counter the DRE testimony, offering alternative interpretations of the evidence presented.
3. Understanding of Rights: Defendants should be fully aware of their legal rights during the DUI investigation process, ensuring that any evidence was obtained lawfully.
4. Challenging Toxicology Reports: Toxicological evidence supporting DRE conclusions must also be scrutinized, focusing on potential lab errors or mishandling of samples.
In navigating DUI charges that involve drug impairment, understanding the role of Drug Recognition Experts is crucial. These highly trained law enforcement officers significantly shape the direction of DUI investigations and legal proceedings with their evaluations. For defendants, having a knowledgeable Orange DUI attorney who can effectively challenge DRE evidence and present a compelling defense is essential to achieving the best possible outcome in such cases.
Free Consultation With An Orange DUI Lawyer
At The Law Office of EJ Stopyro we offer a free and confidential consultation with an experienced Orange DUI lawyer. Call us today at (949) 278-6353 to schedule your consultation.